Topper Copies

The language of narrow nationalism held at Frankfurt destroyed the German Revolution; as the fatal idea of aggrandizement of the House of Savoy destroyed the Italian Revolution." Discuss.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

The German and Italian quest of unity formed a glorious chapter in Europe (1814-1871), suffering a roadblock in 1848 revolution for different reasons.

Narrow Nationalism in Frankfurt in 1848

Impact of 1848 Revolution

- Decided to grant constitution to German state - form a united Germany with Prussian king as Head. - Elected a Frankfurt Assembly to formulate constitution.

Concerns for Frankfurt Assembly

- Nature of Unification - Austria - Grossdeutschland - without Austria - Kleindeutschland - Austria declared either all or non of Austrian empire would join. Allowing lead by Austria - Delays - Long debates on clauses of Constitution like freedom of speech, liberty, democracy. - Failure - Prussian king became impatient & turned to conservative sections like Bismarck who called it "crown of shame" (Frye) Prussian king rejected constitution and German unification by liberals failed in 1848

Idea of Aggradisement of House of Savoy

- 1848 revolution post Naples-Sicily and pope granted Constitution Charles Albert (House of Savoy) decided to take up issue of unification However, he was defeated in Battle of Custoza, following reasons:- 1. Accepted support of only those who promised allegience to him 2. Fragmented efforts - the Italian states did not coordinate among themselves during battle against Austria 3. Disparate efforts - like Rome made Republic by Mazzini & Garibaldi, concerning Pope of republicanism 4. Pope rescinded support swearing of conflict between Christian states 5. Naples-Sicily also withdrew army on threat of Austria a loss of powers

However, both events created ground for future success in unification. Prussia took up baton of Germany albeit in different forms, while House of Savoy with Victor Emmanuel & Cavour decided to create Italy by diplomacy & war.