"Railway development in India provides an interesting instance of private enterprise at public risk". Critically evaluate.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Railways, introduced by Railway Minutes (1850) by Dalhousie, has been a centre of debate by historians like Sabyasachi Chattagee calling it private enterprise at public risk.
Causes of above statement
- Guarantie System - Assured return of 5%. (above market rate) - lease of 99 years with compensation as premature withdrawal - Profits by British by losses by Indian taxpayers - Routes: Mainly port to inland to exit of raw material & ensure easy penetration of British export. - Tariff: Higher charges on freight of Indian industries than British - Capital & technology: Minimum technology transfer to India - Coal, iron & personnels imported at twice the cost. - Eco-imperialism: use of Indian forest timber for berths and tribals as forced labour (RC Guha) - Famine: Mike Davis called Railways as agent of victorian Genocide - extraction of Food Surplus.
However, Railways acted as conduit of connection for Indian nationalism, dissemination of ideas and medium for economic growth. Even as symbol of British Imperialism they emerged as tools Indian used to break British fetters