"As a source of ancient Indian history, foreign accounts have advantages as well as shortcomings." Substantiate with proper examples. [15 Marks]
R Mahandhi
Ancient Indian history was learnt from both indigeneous and when corroborated with foreign accounts provide greater understandings.
Advantages of foreign accounts :-
(I) Political structure (a) Megasthenes - Indica provides details about chandra Gupta maurya's empire activities. (b) Fa Hien - helped in understanding Chandra Gupta - II administration. (c) Hieun Tsang - provided the benevolence of Harsha's empire.
(II) Economic Status (a) Indica mentions "India is a wine of plenty, famine and scarcity are unknown to them." - [Wealthy society] (b) Plutarch, Strabo, Arrian :- mention about the silk route trade, and alexander's invasion in India.
(III) Social hierarchy (a) Indica - 7 classes existed during mauryan period. (b) Hieun Tsang - Buddhism was Supported by Harsha. (c) Architecture -> The wooden Palace of Mauryan's even Arthashastra didnot mention was covered in Indica. (d) State patronage -> So, had access to better literary sources.
Yet, it had significant challenges :- (a) State sponsored bias, (b) didnot understand the Indian culture well - Eg Society had 4 social Stratification yet Megasthenes thought it is 7. (b) Slavery existed, against Megasthenes' Statement of 'No Slavery'. (c) Delay in compilation:- Sources are written after the writers' returned back - Eg Hiuen Tsang - so, inconsistent in memory. (d) Over exaggeration:- Eg Megasthenes said Ashoka had 6,00,000 soldiers !
Though Foreign sources acted as substantiation for better understanding - It has to be corroborated with other, indigenous sources to take neutral, accurate historical facts.