Topper Copies

"Archaeological sources, Vedic literature and the comparative study of languages help us to determine the Aryan problem in Indian history." Discuss. [15 Marks]

R Mahandhi

The Origin of the aryans remains mystic due to the various theories put forward by Max muller, B.G. Tilak and Dayanandh Saraswati.

The Aryan's migrated in 1500 B.C and started the vedic age - 1500 to 600 B.C.

Various archaedogical sources, literature helps in determining Aryan problem :-

1. Invasion from west asia :- Max muller is in favour of this. (a) the Language and the gods worshipped are Same. Suryyas - Surya (in vedic) (b) William Jones argues the language of Persians is very similar to the aryans'. (c) The Bogaz Koi inscription mentions about aryan gods like Indra and Varuna. - in Hattuses.

(d) Dayanandh saraswati says they were Tibetians (similar culture) (e) B.G. Tilak is in favour of Arctic circle invador theory. (f) Mortimer wheeler - argues they were from central asia as the horses usage and tools align with central asian excavation.

Yet, they are ambiguity :-

1. Persian / Indo - european language as Max muller suggests was not accepted - Indo - european language less syllables | Aryan language More syllables. 2. The lack of pottery of aryan's along the Punjab and western Uttar Pradesh - doesnot align with invader Theory as it was along the travel route. 3. Mere knowledge of the people doesnot necessarily mean they are migrator's - against Mortimer Wheeler's theory.

Though Sources, literature, language comparation are put into debate, the aryan's established vedic age which had its impact in the social- economic structure later.