Topper Copies

'Harsha owes his greatness largely not to any real achievements but to the accounts of two famous men'. Explain. [20 Marks]

R Mahandhi

After the decline of the Guptans an empire building activity started in the North India under the Harsha. By merging Pushyabhuti's of Thaneswar and Maukhari's of Kannauj, he set up a strong empire

1. Banabhatta in his book 'Harsha charita' made harsha the greatest king with strong military and good economic condition. 2. Hieun Tsang, in his book 'Fu Kuki' exaggerated harsha as the most benevolent ruler of that time, undisputed leader.

Yet, they were exaggeration :- 1. Harsha didnot fight against the gauda - Sasanga after rescuing his sister 'Rajyashri' - This shows deviation from banabhatta's claims. 2. In the kannauj assembly, Harsha used capital punishment to the brahmins for setting fire-against Hieun Tsang's claim of benevolence. 3. Hieun said 'India is full of honey' yet during Harsha's time, cowrie shell is used showing decline in economic condition. 4. Bana argued harsha had 60,000 elephants -> This is mere exaggeration ' 5. Greatest ruler yet he didnot win against the chalukyan ruler Pulakesin II in the battle of Narmada. 6. Hieun Tsang influenced Harsha towards buddhism, so, he made Harsha the great', 7. Bana bhatta is harsha's childhood friend, so he made harsha's rule the mightiest. 8. Manipulation of source by Hieun as he wrote Fu Ku Ki after 2 to 3 years of his return to China.

Yet, Harsha indeed contributed few achievements :- 1. the last major empire building activity after the Guptan empire. 2. His benerolence of giving away his assets to the monks, and poor in 'Prayaga assembly' 3. He resisted the chalukyan invasion to the north. 4. Patronaged the literary circle in his court. Eg Mayura, divakara and Banabhatta. 5. Harsha himself made several literary contributions – Nagananda, Priyadharsika and Ratnavalli.

though, Banabhatta and Hieun Tsang made harsha great. Harsha through his own benerolence contributed to make his great.