"The advent of the Mauryan dynasty marks the passage from darkness to the light for the historians." Explain the perspective of the historian V.A. Smith. [15 Marks]
R Mahandhi
The Mauryan dynasty was established by Chandra Gupta Maurya in the 4th century B.C along with the help of chanakya. Its capital is Pataliputra.
Historian V.A. Smith regards Mauryan dynasty as a passage from darkness to light :-
I. Political stability :- - (a) Vast empire building activity after the mahajanapadas. - (b) Nanda's (danananda) was weak yet the Chandra Gupta maurya was strong. - [a sketch map of the Indian subcontinent with the northern and north-western part dotted, labelled "Mauryan Empire"] - (c) V. A. Smith also compared Ashoka to Napolean, arguing about the conquest and his valour.
II. Economical impacts :- - (a) Golden era as peace prevailed. - (b) Increase in money circulation. - (c) V-A. Smith noted that strong ruler invariably led to the increase in productivity than earlier period.
III. Societal causes :- - (a) The religious tolerance and the rise of buddhism and jainism contributed to rise of egalitarian society. - (b) It challenged the earlier brahmanical authoritarianism as argued by him. - (c) Position of women improved- appointment of Persian women bodyguard.
Yet, They were significant deviations 1. The over exaggerated about the achievements and didnot know the ground realities. 2. Didnot understand the societal conditions (similar to Megasthenes). 3. Had bias towards european conquest -> He was much in appreciation for Alexander's conquest. 4. Economy was not good as 12 year famine occured during Chandra Gupta Maurya period.
With corroboration with the literary texts of Megasthenes and Romila Thappar, facts can better be understood.