Discuss how and why the Rajatarangini of Kalhana can be considered as a to be a reliable source of the political history of Kashmir.
R Mahandhi
'Rajatarangini' of Kalhana was a Kashmiri literature. It consists of 8 tarangas (books) giving details about the history of Kashmir.
It is considered to be a reliable source of political history :-
1. Neutrality & impartiality :- He was not patronaged by the ruler (Jayaanand simha), so, there is no eulogy unlike Kshemendra. 2. No love or hate :- Just like a Judge, he just stated the facts. 3. Best sources :- Since, his father worked in the royal court, he got access to royal library. 4. Historical events :- According to him, Gonanda is the 1st ruler. - (a) He mentioned about Ashoka's conquest (in the 1st book), - (b) Kanishkas' attack and the establishment of Kanishkapuram
Important events are mentioned correctly. 5. Political significance :- The rule of Queen Didda & Tunga were provided in detail. 6. His knowledge :- Good comparison from various sources gives authenticity to his work.
Yet, There are challenges in using it as a source
1. Gaps in chronology :- The Utpala dynasty's 15 princes names are left out. 2. Discrimination:- against Queen Didda and her rule. 3. His prejudice & pride:- in Kashmiri rulers and left out significance of other neighbouring rulers. 4. Potential bias:- Since, his father helped him in accessing the royal library, may be favour towards king may exist. 5. Limited sources:- He didnot have access to other buddhist sources for more clarity.
Yet, his book provides the most contemporary and relevant sources of the Kashmiri rulers which was continued by Jonaraja,