Topper Copies

"The tenets of Hindu and Muslim mystics were similar enough that the ground was ripe for syncretic movements involving adherents of both religious." Elucidate.

R Mahandhi

The similarities in both the hindu and muslim mystics under the Bhakti and Sufist movement, made the grounds for cultural syncretism of both religions.

Similarities of both mystics :- 1. Universal love :- Eknath as well as Nanak supported love & equality. 2. Universal brotherhood :-

3. Egalitarian society :- Tulsidas and Nasir ud din Mahmud were the proponents. 4. Against the existing social order :- - (a) Kabir criticised the orthodox sects. - (b) Rabia-ud-Adawiyya did the same in Sufism. 5. Political support :- - (a) Shivaji support Maharashtra bhakti movement. - (b) Iltutmish support Zuhrawadi.

Impacts :- 1. Reduced the oppressive nature of the Brahmins and the orthodox Ulema's. 2. Increased the rights of the women to enter spiritual life. Eg Mirabai. 3. Established values :- like charity, love and equality. 4. Promoted literature and culture - Malfuzat of Nizamuddin Auliya and Ramacharitamanas. 5. Promoted cultural syncretism. Eg Rishi order in Kashmir Sufism followed meditation and ascetic practices of Hinduism.

Yet, there are differences which led to divisions between them:- 1. Resistance from the orthodox sects - especially ulemas criticised Sufism + Hinduism as 'unislamic'. 2. Splits within them,

3. Bhakti was an indigenous origin yet sufism depended on west asia, which was alien to people then. 4. Rulers like Akbar promoted cultural syncretism yet Aurangzeb followed Nazarbandi and rejected emislamic practices. 5. Womens' role was very restricted. 6. Economic life and prosperity led to pursue of materialistic life.

Never the less, Hindu + muslim tenets laid the foundation for common interaction though the later period it declined.