You are the head of the Human Resources (HR) department of a reputed tech company in India that has several high profile national and international clients. It has recently come to your notice that a few employees of the Software Development Team have become irregular and insincere towards their work in the past few months. In the past, this team has been instrumental in timely executing projects, resulting in massive revenue and profits for the company. When you enquire about the issue in detail, you find that many employees including the senior leaders of the concerned team are juggling between multiple jobs. This phenomenon is popularly known as 'moonlighting'. When you ask the employees, most of whom have been high performers, their argument is that doing multiple jobs makes them more skillful and resourceful in their work. Further, their justification is that they have been doing their gigs beyond the usual working hours of the company. Some of them communicate that they face financial constraints and this is a reason for them to pursue the second gig. Others are of the view that it provides them avenues to learn new things, which is of help in their current roles. Thus, a whole network of freelancing has been flourishing secretly. You also get to know that employees in some other departments, like the Testing team, are envious of the Software Development team and secretly express their wish to pursue a similar path. Owing to no specific guidelines, these employees have got a free hand. It has led to multiple issues of productivity and the work culture of the organization and could set a wrong precedent for the other employees, if allowed to continue. On the other hand, firing such a huge number of high performing employees at once is going to add to the attrition rate of the company and loss of talent. The views amongst your colleagues in the HR department is also divided on the issue. You have been entrusted by the senior management to evaluate the situation and take appropriate steps. In this context: (a) Highlight the ethical issues associated with moonlighting. (b) As the HR head of the company, what are the options available to you? (c) Evaluate each of these options and choose the option, which you would adopt, giving reasons.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Recently, TCS and Infosys have released guidelines prohibiting moonlighting by employees. The above case is of a similar issue.
a) Ethical Issues Involved i. Loss to the company (irregular and insincere work by employees) ii. Financial constraints of employees iii. Breach of trust by employees iv. Setting a wrong precedent in the company v. Loss of high performing employees to the company vi. Improving skill set of employees and providing avenues to learn
b) Options Available i. Dismissing the employees from the job to set a precedent ii. Allowing them to continue gig work, considering financial constraints and skill development iii. Giving them a strict warning to leave gig jobs, and terminating employees found in violation of guidelines
c) Evaluating the Options
Option (i) - Dismissing
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Precedent for other employees | Loss to the company (talent) | | In the long run will help the company (new talent) | Might benefit competitors |
Option (ii) - Allowing
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Efficiency might increase due to new skill | Setting wrong precedent for others | | Consideration of worker (financial, skill will be acknowledged) | Loss to company due to inefficient work force |
Option (iii) - Warning (Strict)
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Will benefit the company | Loss of some workforce in the short term | | Sets the right precedent for employees | Financial burden on workers (low salary) |
My approach → Option (iii)
Reasons: - Discourages other workers from pursuing dual roles - Financial gain for the company due to an efficient workforce - Even Krishna in the Mahabharat had advised Arjun to fight for dharma, whatever it takes
Thus, termination of unethical employees who don't follow rules despite guidelines is not wrong.