Topper Copies

"The Dyarchy system introduced in 1919 failed to fulfil Indian national aspirations due to its inherent flaws and limitations." Elaborate.

Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025

Dyarchy introduced in act of 1919 gave provision of transferred and Reserved Subject in provinces.

Inherent flaws and limitations 1. Transferred and Reserved Subjects → important Subject like Irrigation, law order kept by Governor. 2. power without responsibility - Governor have powers over the Subjects, not accountable to legislature 3. Hinderance in implementing policy - Ministers didn't have powers to bring strong welfare policy. 4. Veto retained with Governors 5. Conflict with Secretaries - they were not accountable to Ministers. 6. Ministers could be removed by Governor and also through impeachment, but no check on governor. 7. Division of Subjects remained a point of conflict.

Hence act of 1919 was designed to perpetuate Colonial rule, without delegating responsibility to Indians.