Discuss how and why the Rajatarangini of Kalhana can be considered as a to be a reliable source of the political history of Kashmir.
Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025
Kalhana has been accorded a very high position as an early medieval historian composed in the 11th century, the Rajtarangini ("river of kings") is an important source of historical reconstruction.
CONTENT & SIGNIFICANCE
1. Divided into 12 books, the text deals with the reign of different kings until Jayasimha's reign. 2. The first 4 books provide dry political details of rulers following the battle of Kurukshetra. - Important are references to Ashoka the Mauryan ruler who is said to have established various stupas & monasteries in Kashmir. - Kalhana also notes the brief rule of the Huna king, Mihirkula in the mid-6th century. 3. In the next 8 books, Kalhana focuses not just on political details but also social, cultural and natural details. 4. He provides information on reign of Utpala of Aditya dynasty. Kalhana informs us of the various irrigation works taken by the ruler including a reservoir on Jhelum river. 5. He also mentions of Didda, the 11th century queen of Kashmir. Kalhana notes she was ambitious and capable. In general, his writing reflects treatment of women as historically influential figures. 6. Kalhana's method of history writing as per A.L. Basham have many similarities to modern historians - thus before writing, he first undertook a detailed analysis of existing works including land grant charters, writings of past chroniclers etc. 7. Kalhana emphasises on truthful portrayal of facts. Further, as his source of information was his father who was patronised by king Harsha, Kalhana's writing was not aimed to please any patron.
But, it had some deficiencies :-
1. Kalhana displays a bias towards Brahmins. 2. At various places mixes up chronology and mentions contradictory events together. 3. Praises Utpala highly but is very critical of Sidda.
Despite lacunae, Kalhana's work stands as a strong testament to historical consciousness in ancient India.