Was the Caliphate a source and sanction of the legal authority of the Delhi Sultans? Discuss.
Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025
Historians like Haidunath Sarkar have labelled the Delhi Sultanate a 'Theocratic' state that drew its legitimacy from the caliphate.
In the Delhi Sultanate, there was no law of primogeniture. Thus, sultans sought to get letters of investiture from the caliphate to justify their authority to rule.
But, the extent to which the caliphate was a source and sanction for the sultanates legal authority depended on political circumstances and strength of individual sultans -
1. Thus, in 1229, Iltutmish turned the ceremony of receiving the letter of investiture into a grand affair. 2. By Balban's reign, as the sultanate strengthened and consolidated, the ruler claimed to be 'zille-i-ilahi' or shadow of god on earth. - Yet, the caliph's approval of his reign was sought. the khutba and coins continued to be issued in his name. 3. During Alauddin's reign, as the distance between state and religion increased, the ruler declared himself to be a Deputy caliph 4. Whereas, Mubarak shah declared himself to be the caliph. 5. In the reigns of succeeding monarchs, the nominal authority of caliph was recognised only as a tool for optics. 6. By the time of Lodi, only superficial links with the caliphate were maintained.
Thus, while the caliphate served as a tool to justify power, as Sultans became powerful, the importance of caliphate declined.