Topper Copies

Discuss the pattern of constitution changes from the Morely Minto Reform of 1909 to the Government of India Act 1935.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

British constitutional changes from 1909 onwards were done on the pretext of "paternalistic benevolence". But in reality, they were tools to strongly hold India to the empire.

Morley - Minto Reforms 1909

1. For the first time Indians were included in the executive council - Satyendra Prasad Sinha became its very first member. 2. Members of legislative assemblies at centre and provinces were increased. In the latter, non-official members were given a majority 3. Muslim's demand for self-determination led to granting of separate electorates 4. Non-official members were allowed to move resolutions, ask supplementary questions etc.

BUT

1. Through separate electorates, sowed seeds of communalism culminating in partition of 1947. As J. L. Nehru noted, "Muslims have been surrounded by a political wall, isolated from the rest of India". 2. As many non-official members were actually nominated by the govnnd, in essence official majority was retained in provinces.

Government of India Act 1919

1. Voting rights given to populace based on property, education etc. 2. central and provincial budgets separated. 3. Dyarchy introduced in provinces. 4. Bicameral legislature set up at the centre.

BUT

1. Over 70% of the budget was still not-votable. 2. Executive responsibility was not established. Dyarchy created a situation of responsibility but no authority for provincial governments. 3. Representation to provinces at the centre based on their "importance" - thus a highly arbitrary process. 4. Less than 10% of the population could vote. 5. Further divided Indian political lines by extending separate electorates to Anglo- Indians, christians etc.

GOI Act, 1935

1. Aimed to create an all India federation with dyarchy at the centre. 2. Provinces were given full autonomy and bicameral legislatures were established in many like UP, CP etc. 3. voting rights were extended.

BUT

1. As J. L. Nehru noted, "it was a machine with all brakes and no engine". 2. Provincial autonomy diluted by the extensive powers enjoyed by the governor in discharge of his "Special responsibility". 3. He could pass acts / ordinances concurrently with the legislature, stop discussion on any bill or restore rejected budgets. 4. The federation was an attempt to weaken Indian nationalism - by giving 33% seats to princely states, it aimed to keep nationalists within the legislature as a weak lobby.

Despite British attempts to fragment Indian nationalism through self - preserving reforms, they led to political maturity and provided necessary experience for post - 1947 politics.