Topper Copies

"If abdication of British responsibility at the time of transfer of power was callous, the speed with which it was done made it worse." Critically examine.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

As Ian Talbot notes, neither India nor Pakistan were ready for partition. It was a result of British administrative breakdown. Causing the displacement of over 14 million people, it left a lasting scar on the psyche of both nations.

Callous Abdication of British Responsibility

1. As early as February 1947, Clement Attlee declared that if parties don't come to an agreement, power would be transferred to multiple unions. 2. Thus, British neglected Indian unity. 'Balkanisation' of the country seemed imminent. 3. Mountbatten plan (June 1947) contained no provision for protecting the rights of minorities in the new dominions 4. Mountbatten had hoped to be the Governor General of both dominions. But Jinnah kept the position for himself as there was no provision against it. It led to poor communication between the new nations and haphazard migrations

SPEED MADE IT WORSE

1. Radcliffe Award for creating boundaries of the countries was ready by August 13 but Mountbatten announced it only by August 15 so British could shrug off all responsibility from the violence that followed. 2. British troops were withdrawn immediately leading to large-scale violence, massacre and chaos.

Partition was thus traumatic not only due to division of the country but the poor management of the process that followed.