"Badauni possessed an analytic independent mind with different views than official line." Comment.
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Badauni's work Muntchab-ut-twarikh provides history of Akbar's reign, and it is crucial primary source that provides multidimensional view of Akbar's reign.
Badauni's work and difference with Abul fazal's Ain-i-Akbari
- Abul fazal's book toed the official line. He, as a court historians never wrote any bad works of akbar.
Badauni's view on akbar.
- He was critical of Akbar religious policy; Badauni was himself as outhdox muslim, he disliked akbar's eclectic policies, labelled him as 'heretics'. - He commented that "Akbar was thinking to convert to christianity'. - He condemned Akbar's declaration of Mazhar" , heavily criticised Tauhid - i - illahi and ibadatkhana. - Badauni was also critical of the pro-Hindu policy of Akbar. Considered that Akbar was deviating from islamic principles.
Criticism of Badauni's work
- Badauni was an outhdoy Muslim, he was critical of every policy that Akbar started. - Badauni have its own biases and sometimes his works were too critical. - Badauni outhodoyy hampered him to witnesses notable progeress during Akbar's reign.
However Ain-i-Akbari should also be read with Badauni's book to get an independent Judgement of that period.