How far do you agree that the Mughal State was centralized State? Discuss.
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Historian J.N Sarkar, Irfan Habib
Considers Mughal state as centralized state :
Mughal state as centralized state
- Mansabdari System serves as a centralised force, it has twin function → • collection of revenue • general administration. - Mughal sovereign has the sole authority to appoint Mansabdars and grant them rank. - officials like Karkuns, amils, patwaris etc. were appointed by central authority. - Revenue assessment and Jawazil Was sent to the central treasury - Mansabdars were transferred from time to time by the king. - The presence of elaborate Economic Structure, Military system denotes centralised tendencies. - Central Mughal Military might was Capable of Suppressing every rebellious tendencies
Hence it was a centralised State.
However historians like chetan Singh Muzaffar-alam considered it decentralised — Because:—
1. province enjoyed autonomy. 2. Bengal province was a Major source of revenue for the mughal. 3. Bankers and shroffs also enjoyed significant influence on ruling class.
Hence it can be Said that centralising tendencies were present alongwith level of decentralisation.