Examine the various views regarding the role of iron technology in ushering Second Urbanisation in Ancient India. [15 Marks]
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Second phase of urbanization led to the establishment of Mahajanpadas and emergence of cities in northern india around 600 B.C.
Role of Iron technology in second urbanisation 1. Historians R.S Sharma and D.D Kosambi have argued that use of Iron technology led to large-scale destruction of forest and it supported agriculture in the gangetic valley. Iron is widely used for making agriculture equipment and it caused expansion in agriculture led to creation of surplus production which is vital for emergence of cities. However Amalnanda Ghosh has Criticized it and argued that forest of the gangetic valley could be cleared through burning and there is no evidence of large scale use of Iron in this period. 2. Ghosh and Chakrabarty have argued that use of iron neither started the urbanisation nor predates it, but it was the gradual development of state institutions, Monarchy and trade network that led to urbanization 3. Makhan Lal has also dismissed Iron technology use theory and argued that the gangetic valley remain forested till colonial period. and during the colonial period rapid expansion of railway and agriculture caused deforestation 4. Ranjan Gurukul has also refuted the theory in the Context of South India.
Hence their is divergence of views among Historians, but it can be concluded that technological determinism could not alone led to urbanization during the mahajanpada period.