"Though Archaeological evidence does not give direct access to the possible social and political dimensions of the decline of the Harappan civilization, it does indicate that the Harappan culture underwent a gradual process of de-urbanization". Comment. [15 Marks]
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Harappan civilization (2600-1700 B.C) located in the North-west part of Subcontinent is considered as the earliest urban civilization.
The cities declined in the Middle of 1st Millenium B.C due to variety of factors.
Decline of Harappan civilization 1. Archeological evidence doesn't give direct information as there is lack of any evidence related to sudden destruction: Mortimer Wheeler theory of Aryan invasion is discarded now. 2. Archeology doesn't give evidence about political structure, large scale Migration and the political factors for decline like wars. 3. There is lack of evidence about Invasion and Sudden decline as Some cities like Ojiyana, Rakhigarhi were flourishing.
However it's believed that Harappan civilization gradually declined.
Gradual process of de-urbanization 1. Shireen Ratnagar argued that decline of trade with Mesopotamia led to economic disintegration of Harappan cities, however this theory is criticized by Chakraborty and Jim shaffer. 2. Ecological imbalance theory of fairservis suggest that due to population growth and pressure on environment led to resource scarcity and this led to Migration of population. 3. Dales, Lambric, have argued that change in the flow of indus cause the decline of cities and agriculture. 4. R. Adhikari Moonsoon link theory argued that change in the Moonsoon pattern led to decline.
However it is widely understood that while all this factor have played role in de-urbanization, it was not a sudden process but a gradual decline of Harappan cities, which cause de-urbanization