"An ideology of paternalistic benevolence, sometimes coupled with rhetoric of trusteeship and preparation for self-government, barely masked the stark realities of a Raj that was firmly white and autocratic." Critically examine.
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
The ideology of paternalistic benevolance emerged from the Utilitarian thinking and British belief in White man's burden : However this paternalistic benevolance was not true character of Raj .
Criticism of ideology of paternalistic benevolence
1. British continued policy of Racism - Controversy surrounding Vernacular press act , and ilbert bill controversy highlighted the deep seated racism against indians . - Civil service was not opened till late 19th century . 2. Modernization was an aborted Modernization. 1. Education was brought to suit their own administrative needs. - Railways were introduced to suit their economic needs. - industrialization ruined traditional handicraft industry. 3. Paternalistic benevolance was aristocratic - Benefited upper class of indians. - Revenue System ruined peasantry - military top post were reserved for Britishers !
Hence in a nutshell paternalistic benevolence was designed to exploit indians and legitimize their own rule in India.