Although some concepts of Buddhism might trace their roots to Vedic-Upanishadic traditions, Buddhism emerged as a distinct religion with its own unique principles and institutions. Discuss. [15 Marks]
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Buddhism emerged as a Social Movement that impacted every facets of life.
Buddhism -Vedic uprishadic route - Both originated in gangetic valley. - focus on liberation of individual - against ritual and dogemans of Brahminism. - Chandogya uprishad and Taitreya emerged due to criticism of vedas. - Similarities on emphasis on Gyanmarg etc.
Rhys david and Radkrishnan consider Buddhism root to uprishad.
Buddhism a distinct religion with its own unique principle and institution Principles - Deny the authority of vedas while upnishad considered as [?] - Deny existence of Soul while upnishad believes in it - Didn't subscribe to the Concept of Atman and Brahman - Buddhist Dharma was Hired action, speech, conduct in day to day life but upnishad Dharma is duty. - Buddhism silent about god's existence, upnishad believes in it - Upnishad — Monotheism Buddhism → Rebirth, Boddhisattvas etc
Newer institutions of Buddhism - Sangha → Buddhist Monks lived in Sanghas, live by wandering and Bhiksha. - Women admitted into Sangha, a Radical departure from different religion. - allowed lower caste people to join it, Social Mobility for vaishyas increased.
Ending → Mahayana accepted Sanskrit → Corruption in Sanghas
However Buddhism is new experiment in the religious domain separate from vedic religion.