Topper Copies

"Though the Act of 1919 was superseded by that of 1935, the preamble to the former was not repealed- the preservation of the smile of Cheshire cat after its disappearance, and the latter said nothing about dominion status." Comment.

Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025

Act of 1935 was brought after Round table Conferences and Simon Commission Recommendation - However It has Several retarding features.

Criticism of Act of 1935 1. Preserved the Core of 1919 act - Governor general power was Kept intact - ordinance power. - Veto to Governor, no Responsible govt. at centre. - Although Dyarchy abolished in provinces, Governor Retained exclusionary power - can Remove Ministers - Defence, foreign affairs Controlled by Governor General. 2. There was no provision of independence and dominion states - it was designed to absorb leaders into constitutional and electoral politics → 1937 election - No provision of constitution of Constituent assembly.

Tomlinson argued that 1935 act was designed to protect British rule by attracting collaborators, Nehru called it Engine with all brake.

Hence it was envisaged to create paper federation, but there was no significant progress from 1919 Act.