'Harsha owes his greatness largely not to any real achievements but to the accounts of two famous men'. Explain. [20 Marks]
Diamond Singh Dhruw, AIR 623, 2025
Harsha (606-647 AD) was the powerful ruler of the Pushyabhuti dynasty and his reign was considered as significant period of ancient India.
Harsha's greatness mentioned by Banabhatta -> wrote Harshacharita - Hien Tsang -> Chinese traveller visited during Harsha's reign in the 17th Century. (Si-yu-ki Book) - Harsha himself wrote books Nagananda, Ratnavali and Priyadarshika, all this extoll his virtues.
Harsha's greatness in Harscharita
- Banbhatta gave depiction of Harsha's early life. → His rise to power in kannauj - Harsha brother was killed and his Sister Rajshri was captured by Shashanka, Harsha attacked Garda kingdom to avenge this. - Harsha's empire extended from Assam to North west and in the south to the Malwa. - Banbhatta mentions about Harsha's literary genious & his books. - He mentions that Banskhera inscription is signed by Harsha ... - He extolls the size of Harsha army. - also shows Harsha's time as land of Sakal Uttarapatha and Siladitya - He also mentioned about Kannauj and Prayagraj assembly. - and gave details about Harsha's courage and virtue.
Hiuen-Tsang account of Harsha's reign
1. He Eulogized Harsha's reign as Harsha patronised Buddhism - He mentioned that punishment were Mild , empire was rich. - He also mentions about the affluence of Kannauj - He mentions that Harsha didn't sleep and eat and work tirelessly for people. - He also mentions about generous nature of Harsha
However Banbhatta and Hien Tsang has been criticed for their biased Judgements. - Banbhatta was childhood friend of Harsha. he only eulogised his Patron. - He didn't Mentioned about Harsha's defeat against pulkeshin II ! - Harsha's literary achievement seems to be exaggerated. - His explaination of army is exaggerated. - Hien Tsang eulogised Harsha's as he patronised Buddhism, his account is po foreigner perspectives and hence lacked Critical Judgement
Hence although Harsha was a great ruler, but Much of his greatness is attributed to work of Banbhatta & Hien Tsang.