Prateek Kumar, the Project Manager, is in charge of the construction of a highly anticipated highway that is expected to drive regional development. The project aims to enhance connectivity, boost trade, and create substantial employment opportunities. Given its importance, it has become a focal point for the ruling party, which is actively promoting it as a symbol of progress ahead of the upcoming state elections next year. The timely completion of the highway is crucial, as the Chief Minister is scheduled to inaugurate it upon completion. This has led to added pressure on Prateek and his team to meet the approaching deadline, which is set for next month. During a routine inspection, Prateek discovers that a particular stretch of the highway has been built with substandard materials. This section fails to meet the required safety and durability standards, posing a serious threat to public safety and lives. If left unresolved, the compromised quality could lead to accidents, undermining both the project's credibility and the government's promises for safe and reliable infrastructure. Concerned, Prateek raises the issue with the contractor, but the contractor downplays the severity, claiming that minor adjustments will fix the problem without causing major delays. In a subsequent team meeting, some senior members suggest that Prateek overlook the quality concerns to ensure the project remains on schedule. They argue that the majority of the highway meets standards and emphasize the severe economic and political consequences of delays. With elections approaching, they stress the importance of the Chief Minister's inauguration as a key political event. They warn that any delay could damage the ruling party's image, harm its electoral prospects, and potentially have repercussions for the team and the organization. Later, the contractor privately approaches Prateek with a substantial bribe, urging him to ignore the issue and allow the project to proceed. The contractor justifies his actions by citing financial pressures and the need to complete the project on time. Prateek is an honest and upright officer, but he understands that addressing the problem would delay the project, making it impossible to meet the deadline. (a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. (b) Under the given conditions, what are the options available to Prateek as the Project Manager? Critically evaluate each of the options. (c) What option should Prateek adopt and why?
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
The present situation discloses the following stakeholders ->
(a) Ethical issues The primary ethical issue raised is political and economic concerns putting a question upon public safety and value of human life.
(b) Options available (i) leave issue unresolved.
Positives 1. smooth implementation of service delivery. 2. Timely completion 3. low cost
Negatives 1. Risk to lives 2. structural defect left unaffected.
(ii) Raise issue through appropriate channel
Positives 1. Protects public safety 2. upholds quality
Negatives 1. Delays & economic cost. 2. Action against organization, transfer etc. of Prateek.
(iii) Seek to address issue & expedite work through innovation practices
Positives 1. Dynamic method 2. Possibility of timely completion 3. No risk
Negatives 1. may take time 2. may lead to "bad press" if delayed
(c) Option to be adopted Prateek has to adopt the third option because it upholds the innate value of human beings as "ends in themselves" (Kant).
Course of action - 1. Enquiry & fact finding on extent of structure risk. 2. Due documentation and action on contractor for lapses. 3. Taking inspiration from Shri E Sreedharan who prefabricated some metro stations to meet deadlines, Prateek should - (i) find innovative, cost effective method of repair (ii) ensure timely completion through "reverse clock" (eg. DMRC policy) (iii) constantly monitor progress to ensure high quality of completion
This is the best course of action as it upholds quality of service delivery, ensures timelines are met, keeps costs low and prioritizes public safety. As Shri T.N. Seshan observed an officers duty is to the people and the constitution, and not to political masters.