Littering at popular tourist destinations has become a significant environmental and ethical concern in India. A recent incident highlighted this issue when tourists were observed throwing tissue papers and a cake box on the road after celebrating a birthday. When a local politely requested them to use a nearby dustbin just 5 feet away, the tourists dismissed the appeal, claiming no dustbin was available. The situation escalated when their driver threw a plastic bag into the adjacent valley. Public reactions to the incident were divided. Some individuals commended the intervention as an effort to promote civic responsibility, emphasizing the need to protect fragile ecosystems like hill stations. Many argued that tourists must adhere to basic environmental ethics and that public spaces are a shared responsibility. Critics also highlighted the broader implications of such irresponsible behavior on the environment and local livelihoods. On the other hand, the tourists involved accused those intervening of interfering in their personal affairs, claiming their privacy was being violated. The argument that the tourists were being publicly shamed through the viral video added another layer to the ethical debate. Many questioned whether posting such incidents online, even for a social cause, was appropriate or necessary. The debate continues, with one side emphasizing the collective responsibility to preserve public spaces and the environment, while the other raises concerns about individual privacy and autonomy. (a) What are the ethical concerns associated with tourists littering at public destinations? (b) How can ethical tourism practices be integrated into policies to address issues like littering at tourist destinations? (c) Suggest a course of action that balances environmental responsibility and individual rights. Justify your answer.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
This situation highlights classic dilemma of using social media as a tool of accountability in its encroachment of privacy of individuals.
(a) Ethical Issues
(b) Integrating ethical tourism practices 1. Sensitization of tourists. eg. signs of "no littering". 2. use "consistency effect" by making tourist sign "no littering" declarations. 3. E.S. -> nudge behaviour by rewarding ethical waste collection. 4. Advertising ecotourism as an "aspirational experience" to derive behaviour change. 5. use of social media influencers to derive attitude change. 6. Integrated systems approach - (i) only permit "non polluting" tourist project (ii) adequate waste disposal arrangements (iii) strict fines.
(c) Balanced Course of Action In the present situation, we have to take a proportionate approach, which as per Supreme Court in Modern Dental Association v UOI, means that - (i) social welfare must be upheld with, (ii) minimal rights violation.
Alongside, we must uphold the principle of "Polluter Pays" (as per Stockholm Summit) by internalizing upon polluting tourists the social costs of pollution.
This requires a caliberated approach - (i) Reporting mechanism for polluting tourists -> can upload pictures to an app, issue to be taken up by service provider, else the hotel to be fined (in line with IT rules of intermediary liability) (ii) strict fines and ban from tourist place in repeat offender cases. (iii) social media videos may only be uploaded to raise awareness of issues upon blurring faces -> no uploading of identity to social media without consent.
This approach brings an institutional solution to the problem, addressing rights of all stakeholders, including the environment.