Inside a busy city administration office, Joint Municipal Commissioner Keerthi, who also serves as the Public Information Officer (PIO), faces a challenging situation. Recently, an RTI application has been received, demanding details about public infrastructure projects initiated during her tenure. Upon reviewing the requested information, Keerthi discovers that certain decisions made regarding these projects were not entirely sound in hindsight. These decisions, although taken in good faith and after due diligence, failed to realize promised outcomes. There were other employees also who were party to this decision. The disclosure of this information could potentially lead to scrutiny and backlash against herself, the employees, and contractors involved. Known for her integrity and commitment to public service, Keerthi finds herself at a crossroads. The RTI Act has served as a critical check against administrative arbitrariness, ensuring transparency and accountability. However, she also observes a troubling trend. RTI applications are often used by vested interests and activists seeking personal gain rather than genuine public interest. Some activists even resort to threats or extortion tactics, undermining the integrity of the RTI process. She fears the requested RTI information could be similarly exploited. Moreover, the employees involved are requesting her to withhold the information. In navigating this situation, Keerthi weighs her options carefully. (a) Critically examine the options available to Keerthi in the above situation. (b) Which of the above would be the most appropriate for Keerthi and why?
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
This situation shows a challenging situation where good faith decisions could not yield correct outcomes, showing "intention - outcome" gap.
(a) Options available (i) Hide details and not reveal complete information
Positives 1. Prevents unnecessary scrutiny 2. upholds morale 3. vested interests
Negatives 1. Against spirit of RTI 2. Against accountability 3. Incentivizes inefficiency
(ii) Reveal complete information
Positives 1. upholds letter & spirit of RTI act. 2. Proactive public disclosures. 3. upholds accountability
Negatives 1. Harassment of bona fide officer 2. Scrutiny may derail work 3. Vested interests
(iii) Go for caliberated approach balancing privacy & accountability
Positives 1. upholds RTI Act and DPDP Act. 2. Accountability tempered with privacy.
Negatives 1. may foster inefficiency. 2. may get overturned on appeal.
(b) Appropriate action The most appropriate action would be to chiefly go for full disclosure as per option (ii), with elements of option (iii) as follows -
(1) major decisions taken and their basis must be revealed (2) Any data or reports that led to decision to be revealed (3) while names of major decision makers may be revealed, where necessarily. (4) Irrelevant details - like details of every subordinate working on an issue, could be avoided. (5) This prevents harassment of office staff while ensuring accountability of primary decision-makers.
This set of decisions - (i) upholds accountability & transparency (ii) shows good faith in revealing the basis of decisions. (iii) incentivizes more efficient & appropriate decisions.
It is not enough for officers to have integrity. Rather they should also show effectiveness in converting "outlays into outcomes" as per the Nolan Committee.
Further, prevalence of false RTIs or use of RTI for extortion is addressed by - (i) malicious prosecution proceedings against extortionists (ii) internal enquiry showing decisions were in good faith -> clean chit if no discrepancies disclosed.
Hence, RTI regime mandates proactive disclosure, and courts must step in to firmly correct instances of vested interest in same manner as fine regime for frivolous PILs.