Topper Copies

"The recognition of the horrors of nuclear weapons should compel nations to move towards meaningful disarmament. However, geopolitical interests continue to hinder genuine progress in this direction. What are the ethical considerations of nuclear states to pursue global disarmament, and how can the international community balance security concerns with the moral imperative of a nuclear-free world?

Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025

Global disarmament is a sine qua non for lasting global peace. However, effects at disarmament are impeded by the following ethical considerations -

(i) Survival spirit, which is the "will to life" (Freud)

(ii) mutual suspicion that others will retain weapons

(iii) Domination instinct to accumulate more hard power.

(iv) National interest dictates that defenses be robust.

(v) Utilitarian scruple of retaining nuclear weapons -> foster peace by threat of "mutually assured destruction".

Balancing needs 1. International treaties that go for complete disarmament -> unlike NPT, which only targets non nuclear countries. 2. Transparent mechanism -> mutual trust that disarmament efforts are not asymmetrical. 3. Liberal I.R. theory -> trade interdependence leads to mutual trust, leads to disarmament. 4. Gradual de-escalation approach, practised since 1970s of reducing warheads

Hence, disarmament is a gradual process to be built on shared trust & transparency.