Topper Copies

What do you understand by the term "Conflict of Interest"? How does it manifest in the decision making by public servants? In what ways can it be minimized?

Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025

"Conflict of Interest" refers to a bias introduced because a persons personal interests get into conflict with their public role as administrator or adjudicator.

Manifestations 1. Subject matter bias | eg. a homophobic person deciding on entitlements of LGBTQIA+. 2. Pecuniary bias | where public servants stand to gain from decisions. eg. road route such that it is near property of officer. 3. Personal bias | eg. appointment committee headed by senior officer considering employment of his son. 4. Procedural Bias - veto is vested with chairperson, or where other officials do not get effective say.

Addressing bias 1. Immediately record conflict of interest. 2. Recuse from decisions involving bias, where possible. 3. Disclose in advance -> reconstitution of search committee etc. 4. Sensitization to reduce subject matter bias - eg. gender sensitization. 5. Fair processes with equal voice to all.

Lord Acton said that "justice must not just be done, but seen to be done". Hence every bias - real or perceived must be duly addressed in administrative decision making.