Topper Copies

You are leading a rescue operation in a flood affected area. The flood has wreaked havoc and thousands of people and their homes are stranded in deep water. There has been a severe shortage of food and drinking water since the last few days. Because of the difficult topography of the area and heavy rainfall, the rescue operation is taking a lot of time. You have also lost information about one of your rescue team members who has become untraceable. It has been one of the most challenging assignments of your life. When your team finally reaches one of the rescue spots, the people there abuse and assault your man because of the pent-up anger. The remaining team members are now requesting you to call off the rescue operation as they are worried about their own safety. Also, your efforts are being shown in a negative light by the print and electronic media. Identify the ethical dilemma involved. How will you handle the situation in such circumstances? List the qualities which should be at display by the officer in such circumstances.

Apala Mishra, AIR 9, 2020

This is a challenging case where my responsibility lies both towards my subordinates and also towards the people of my country.

The ethical dilemmas involved are:-

1. Self interest v/s Public interest. 2. Duty towards team members v/s Duty towards citizens. 3. Duty without rewards/appreciation v/s Negative light of print & electronic media.

Handling the situation

1. I will talk to my team members about the exact situation.

2. Since all lives are equally important, I will convince my teammates and bring up/boost their morale.

3. Since I am the leader, I will try to lead by example by not losing courage and stability myself.

4. After analyzing the entire situation with teammates, we may like to ask authorities for better & more rescue equipments in more numbers on an urgent basis.

5. While I myself will not be having the time to reach out to the media, I will ask a member of my team to speak to the media and tell them the progress and situation.

6. After reaching the rescue posts, I will convince the people that all efforts are being made to save their lives in very less time. Essential commodities like drinking water can be given to them on the spot to make them feel a bit relieved and to garner trust.

7. After completion of the operation, awareness needs to be spread about disaster management in flood situations. NDMC guidelines need to be made public and it should be ensured that it doesn't happen again.

Qualities

1. Courage - to face the situation. 2. Rationality & Wisdom - to make the right choice. 3. Emotional intelligence - to maintain emotional stability during stressful situation. 4. Empathy & compassion - to feel the pain of the people & be motivated to end their suffering.