You are working a Sub Divisional Magistrate in a district with natural resources. A powerful organized mafia in the district has come under your scanner which has been indulging in illegal mining. You want to act, but you have received direct threats from them. You have also been promised incentives for not taking any action. On seeking advice from your immediate superior, you are advised to turn a blind eye to the whole issue. You contacted the mining department head in the state capital for the same reporting both - the issue and the advice of your superior. Your department head advises you to listen to your superior or seek a transfer. You once again take up this issue with your superior. Your superior tells you that many people are employed as labourers and daily wage workers by the illegal mining industry. This will ruin livelihoods and lead to local unrest. a) What are the possible courses of actions for you in the given circumstances? b) What course of action will you finally choose and why?
Apala Mishra, AIR 9, 2020
The stakeholders involved are:-
a) The courses of action available are:-
1. Complaining to the highest authority available. 2. Involving the media. 3. Seeking transfer. 4. Resigning from the post. 5. Listening to superior & turning a blind eye to the situation.
b) Preferred course of action
1. I will speak to my superior again asking him to form a team so that we can view alternate options.
2. Speak to the head of ministry of labour regarding the labourers. Talk about alternatives such as channelizing them into MGNREGA or a legal mining authority.
3. If my superior doesn't agree, I might like to reach even higher authorities regarding the situation.
4. I will then give notice to the illegal mining mafia. Taking help from the Police at this stage might be desirable.
5. After giving notice, I will make sure that the mining work is stopped, and compensatory damages are provided.
6. Those compensatory damages can be used to rehabilitate the workers.
7. Involving the media will be the last step - but also necessary to spread awareness regarding illegal activities happening in the country.
'Moral muteness' leads to destruction of society, thus, being a civil servant, I will make sure that I am morally correct, while at the same time using my emotional intelligence to stop myself from being too irrational.