You are an anthropologist assigned to stay with a tribe which lives in deep forests. You should prepare a case study regarding their ways of living and culture. You have been asked to study them without interfering in their rituals and culture. You realize that the tribe practices selective infanticide based on their religious beliefs, and have unintentionally been a witness to it. Some people from the adjoining areas have filed a complaint against this to the police. You have been summoned to the Police Station for questioning. Answer the below questions based on the information provided above. a) What choices do you have? b) Every choice that you make will have a negative and a positive impact. Analyse the consequences of each of your choices.
Apala Mishra, AIR 9, 2020
This is a case where objective scholarly endeavours and social sensitivity collide.
The stakeholders are - 1. Tribal people and their tradition. 2. People of adjoining area who look up to the police for justice/fairness. 3. Police - who has to serve justice.
a) Choices available are:-
- Lie to the police about witnessing the infanticide. - Tell the police about the act & leave the situation onto them. - Be an active social citizen, keeping in mind both the police & tribals. Giving details to the police while ensuring sensitivity towards the tribe. Forming a standard of procedure - helping the police reach decisions since I know the tribes closely.
b) Merits & Demerits
1) Lying to the police
Merits - It will keep the tribals safe since the police might put them in jail
Demerits - Ethically wrong act from deontological perspective
2) Tell the police & leave the situation
Merits - It will be free of stress/pain (Egoistical Hedonism) - I would be truthful & honest in accordance with deontology
Demerits - Leaving the tribe to their own fate after knowing them so closely. - Police might not be able to understand them & might use brutal force. - I will not be showing values of courage & justice :. not being virtuous.
3) Forming a standard of Procedure, helping the police & the tribes
Merits 1. Win-win situation 2. I will not be shying away from my responsibility. 3. I will be making the best application of my knowledge.
Demerits 1. Tribes might have to give up their traditional religious custom.
Preferred Course of Action
1. Tell the police the truth. 2. Convince them that you have studied the tribes closely and any irrational action might do more harm than good. 3. Form a standard procedure - involve any NGOs which have been associated with the tribe. 4. Convince the tribe to stop such a practice showing them the disadvantage. Talk to tribal leaders. 5. Continuous monitoring by frequent visits.