Topper Copies

The increasing use of digital surveillance technologies for maintaining law and order is a debatable issue. Critically examine the statement from the ethical point of view.

Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025

Increasing use of digital surveillance tech is a two-edged sword - deriving efficient law enforcement but raising privacy concerns.

Efficacy of law enforcement 1. Evidentiary value of video evidence with BSA -> recording traffic violations, abuse of power etc. 2. Digital Surveillance of conversations -> unearthing conspiracy, organized crime. eg. NCRB drug busts. 3. Digital Surveillance of public places -> womens safety and quick response. eg. "he wim you" app. 4. Used in counter-terror to track radicalization over social media - eg. ISIS Telegram groups

Privacy concerns 1. Facial Recognition Tech -> citizen profiling -> pointed out by Internet Freedom Foundation. 2. Access to private chats, search history -> violation of digital privacy as per K.S. Puttaswamy case. 3. "Thought monitoring" by internet monitoring -> "big brother" effect of thought policing. 4. Treating people as "means to an end" (collective security) and not "ends in themselves". 5. Violates Frankls doctrine of "looking for the best in people" since it assumes the worst.

Hence, deployment of such technology should be based on principle of necessity (ECHR) -> infringement of privacy should be only to the extent strictly necessary to uphold security of all.