A heavy hemispherical shell of radius r has a particle attached to a point on the rim, and rests with the curved surface in contact with a rough sphere of radius R at the highest point. Prove that if $R/r > \sqrt{5} - 1$, the equilibrium is stable, whatever be the weight of the particle.
Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025
[a hemispherical shell resting with its curved surface on a larger sphere, with a vertical axis through O, O' and the centre; points labelled O, 4', r, O', R, m', angle $\alpha$ marked]
Figure is as shown
COM of hemisphere = 4
=> $O4 = \frac{3r}{8}$
=> $O4' = \frac{3r}{8}\cos\alpha$
=> $O'4' = r - \frac{3r}{8}\cos\alpha$ ( height of COM of hemisphere )
Eqbm is stable if $h$ (height of combined COM) $< \frac{Rr}{R+r}\cos\alpha$
[a small right triangle with vertices labelled O, 4'' and m', an angle marked, with 4' labelled below]
=> height of $m'$ = $4''O'$ = $r - r\sin\alpha$