Topper Copies

Discuss the inherent contradictions in synthesising Law and Compassion. How can law be made more compassionate?

Apala Mishra, AIR 9, 2020

Law is 'an ordinance of reason made by someone who has care for the community' - St Thomas Aquinas.

Compassion is the feeling of concern & empathy in response to the sufferings of others leading to an inherent motivation for alleviating the suffering & embracing the distressed.

Contradiction in synthesizing Law & Compassion

1. While law demands objectivity, compassion is concerned with feelings of empathy and sensitivity. eg: Showing compassion towards illegal migrants - against law. Some people showing compassion towards Burhan Wani - against law.

Law can be made more compassionate by:-

1. Breaking the shackles of traditional colonial laws and bringing in traditional values in amalgamation with new-age laws. 2. Sensitivity training of police officials 3. Sensitizing district administration towards compassionate practices. 4. Public participation / heads of civil society and views of all sections of society can be gathered before amending law.

Law is the backbone of our administration and hence must be synthesized with compassion upto acceptable levels.