Topper Copies

A uniform string of weight $W$ is suspended from two points at the same level and a weight $W'$ is attached to its lowest point. If $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are the inclinations to the horizontal of the tangents at the highest and lowest points, prove that $$\frac{\tan \alpha}{\tan \beta} = 1 + \frac{W}{W'}$$

Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025

[a horizontal line with points A (left) and B (right) at its ends, a U-shaped curve hanging from A and B with its lowest point labelled O, and a dashed line continuing from O down and to the right to a point labelled O']

$W'$ be suspended at $O$

$O'$ is point assuming we had catenary

at $O$ tension be $T$

$\Rightarrow$ [a force diagram at a point on a horizontal line: two tensions T, T drawn as arrows going up-left and up-right, with angles β and β between each arrow and the horizontal, and a downward arrow labelled W']

$\Rightarrow 2T\sin\beta = W'$

By property of catenary

$T = \frac{W'}{2l} y = \frac{W'}{2l} c \sec\beta$

($2l$ being length of catenary)

$\Rightarrow \sin\beta \frac{W'}{l}$ ($\sec\beta = W'$ [?]

$\Rightarrow \tan\beta = \frac{l W'}{c W}$ - ①

$O'O = c \tan\beta$

$O'A = c \tan\alpha = O'O + l$

(Property of catenary $S = c \tan\psi$)

$\Rightarrow c \tan\alpha = c \tan\beta + l$

$\Rightarrow l = c(\tan\alpha - \tan\beta)$

Put in ①

$\Rightarrow \tan\beta = \frac{(\tan\alpha - \tan\beta) W'}{W}$

$\Rightarrow \frac{\tan\alpha}{\tan\beta} - 1 = \frac{W}{W'}$