The heaviest penalty for declining to rule is to be ruled by someone inferior.
Shakti Dubey, AIR 1, 2024
American Revolution is the earliest revolution that the world has seen, which led to cascading effect inspiring revolutions across the worlike like- The French Revolution, Russian revolution, etc.
"NO Taxation without Representation" This slogan still holds relevance even in contemporary times, which was given by the Americans - signifying strength of collective wisdom and reminding British that Power cannot be imposed, it must be earned.
While on the other hand- Asian and African countries remained colonies of British for centuries. The major reason was- Internal division, fractured power structure, lack of belief in self rule by these nation
The heaviest penality that they had to pay declining to govern themselves was to accept to be ruled by someone inferior ie, a foreign nation that had no understanding of their culture, society or for that matter any knowledge about these colonies.
In this essay we will be looking at several dimensions as to how declining to rule may cause harm to oneself. We will also look at the aspect of how it can lead to rule by inferior and how this can impact the person at individual level, societal level and even at national and international level
Plato who is also known as Father of Political Philosphy has given the Theory of Philospher king in his book- The Republic where he talks about the rule by a knowledgeable person, who according to him is a philospher. He clearly states that when a man refuses to be ruled by a philospher he might be ruled by someone inferior ie, a Man of courage or man of appetite who according to him are subordinate to Man of knowledge.
This idea of Plato was based on his experiences in Athens- which was defeated in Peloponessian war by sparta because of lack of a proper rule and this became one of the reason for his antagonism towards Democracy.
Plato justifies the Rule of Philosopher king through concept of Dialectics given by socrates. The principle of dialectics is based on soul-searching, continously introspecting and reflecting on one's actions and decision. This helps a man to acheive True knowledge, and The rule of knowledge is considered to be Supreme.
A Man is not just an individual rather he is a culmination of all the Values, emotions, experiences, etc that he/she posses, and is therefore impacted by these factors as well. This shapes their decision-making power further, Influencing the value system of a society.
Today Climate change has become one of the immediate threat to humankind. According to IPCC 6th Assesment report- with current rate of development & mitigation effect, the global average temperature will rise by 2°C by the end of this century. The reason for this catastrophe is - "Man who chose to be governed by his desires & not by sustainability". Since the advent of Industrial Revolution countries have been in a race to acheive economic growth, gain profit while neglecting the environment
Malala (climate Activist) recently Stated- "We must act as if our house is on fire, because it is". This clearly reflects that - In times to come man will have to pay the heaviest penality because he declined to rule & chose to be ruled by someone inferior ie, his desires.
This is how in different aspects of life man has suffered because of his nature to "decline to rule" and instead by guided by inferior natures
Recently a hoarding in Mumbai collapsed, killing almost 16 people on the spot and investigation revealed that the hoarding was stationed illegaly without proper clearances showing clear absence of corporate ethics as man choses to be guided by his instinct of Profit and decline to live by his principles.
Today in the era of digital technology while life has become more easier and efficient, the threat of cybercrime looms all over. Cyberattacks have been so frequent. According to an American Cybersecurity firm - Resecurity :- 830mn Indians faced breach of data privacy as their personal data- including- Aadhar data, bank details, etc were compromised.
If we ask ourselves the reason for such incidents. The answer is- because man deliberately chose to avoid being his own master & hence was guided by his personal motives.
This has crept into the political system as well - in the form of corruption, criminalisation of politics, etc. Here the lawbreakers are the new law makers
and this dosen't bothers anyone because it has become so normal. This is the penality we as a society are paying because we declined to chose self rule and hence are now ruled by someone inferior ie, corrupt & criminal leaders.
Buddha's 5 Nobel Truths have highlight human nature in a very subtle manner - He says- the world is full of sufferings and the cause of suffering is desire, we conquer our desires - we liberate ourselves from clutches of suffering and this is possible through 8-fold pathway which leads us to true knowledge ie, Kaivalya Gyaan or Nirvaana.
Through philosphy- Buddha himself highlight that when a man choses to decline to rule himself- his inferior Instints becomes his masters & thus become the cause of suffering
Today when we say that the world is moving towards progression - technologically, economically, socially, etc even at this time the world is still witnessing chaos in form of Russia-Ukraine crisis, Israel-Hamas war, Iran-Pakistan conflict Rise of aggressive chinese diplomacy, etc which has lead to negative consequences like- humanitarian crisis, death of civilians, lack of regulations, use of arms & ammunition, loss to property & life, etc.
What could be the reason for such sorry state of Affair? The reason is that leaders these days are ruled by inferior motives like National interest over Global interest. They are guided by animal instict of power & prestige and because of this humanity continues to suffer.
To avoid such crisis man must understand the consequence of their action, they must rise above their emotions & instincts and chose to be his own master, be his own ruler and avoid submitting to any inferior desires.
Just like American rose under their conciousness to revolt against British. Africans & Indian united under the leadership of Mahatama Gandhi to raise their voice. Nations in African & Asian continent chose to be their own master. Indian demanded Swarajya leading to it's Independence after years of colonial rule.
All it requires is conciousness of their rights and liberties. Man must understand the difference between "What is their right & what is the right thing to do"
Just the way India chose to remain Non-aligned post Independence, through this India showed it's reluctance towards any inferior rule and rather opted for Self-Rule.
Despite foreign sanctions & pressure India continued it's Nuclear Tests not to harm any nation but to ensure it's External and internal security. India through it's Nuclear Doctrine which is based on No-First-Use policy, Credible minimum deterrance & second strike Capabilities - has shown the world that "Self-rule" need not be always guided by self-Interest rather it has to be based on benovalent attitude towards the society along with being our own master.
Thus, man must weigh all the options clearly before choosing to submit to their decision. May, societies, nation must chose to rule themselves & be their own masters, because in absence of such positive attitude They will have to pay heavy Penalities in form of rule by Inferior.
Through this entire debate Gandhi's idea of "Swarajya" based on Truth and non-voilence can act as our guiding light