Topper Copies

You are a public representative, elected on the ticket of a political party, considered as conservative by many. Your daughter, who has returned years after studying abroad, has conveyed to you her choice of marrying a person from another community. You personally do not consider anything wrong in her choice, and convey your assent to her. You also discuss it with many among your friends and family, and inform them of a grand wedding ceremony you are planning for your daughter. However, a few days after you have shared the news of the forthcoming grand wedding with many, you are informed by your political secretary about an issue being made of the same. He informs you that there are whispers among many people in your constituency about it, and indications of a sense of unease among some prominent citizens. While most of them are enamoured by your plans for a grand wedding ceremony for your daughter, they are unhappy about the bridegroom being from another community. You also get to know through your sources in the party, that your assent to the choice of the bridegroom may lead to a denial of ticket by the high command in the forthcoming elections. You are not only an ambitious politician and a rising star in your political party but also an open-minded, loving and doting father. But howsoever much you love her daughter's freedom and choices, you do not want her decision to adversely affect your political journey. This is more so, when you had been eagerly looking forward to greater responsibilities and a higher stature in the party, given the years of hardwork you have put in, as a politician. Your daughter, on the other hand, is firm with her choice and does not want her impending grand wedding to be affected in any way. She is adamant that her wedding will not be held as a private ceremony with only close friends and family, but should be publicised in a grand way, as you had promised earlier to her. Given this situation, answer the following: (a) What are the ethical issues in the above situation? (b) What are the various options that you have, as a father and an ambitious politician? (c) What will be your course of action? Justify with proper reasoning.

Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023

Conservative society and taboo associated with inter-caste & inter-religious marriages still exists in the society. Also the lavish nature of weddings points at the iron cage of consumerism.

(a) Ethical issues in the case 1. Political attitude of conservatism ⇒ against constitutional morality. 2. Threat to right to choose partner as covered by Hadiya case under Article 21. 3. Dilemma of professional aspiration vs personal duty to daughter for the politician. 4. Lavish expenditure demand for marriage = materialistic showoff (ostentation) 5. Politics without principle as a Gandhian sin. 6. Tocqueville's warning of herd mentality ⇒ decisions governed by external validation.

(b) Various possible options

1. Deny marriage to the chosen groom for the daughter - Merits → save political career; uphold party line of conservatism - Demerits → duty towards daughter forfeited; selfish

2. Allow marriage with all showoff as demanded - Merits → happy daughter ⇒ upheld right under Art 21; increased prestige due to leadership ⇒ set precedent - Demerits → materialism promoted ⇒ against Buddhist minimalism; loss of political stature

3. Call for simple marriage to chosen groom ⊕ donate excess money for charity - Merits → simplicity in life ⇒ divine virtue; altruism as Gandhi said "If you want to find yourself, lose yourself in service of others"

(c) Course of action I will choose option 3 and additionally - 1. Try to convince the political boss to adopt politics with morality 2. Show how setting right precedent increases prestige. → tell story of Gandhi during Chauri Chaura. 3. Else find a own party if not given ticket for social reform.

Justification 1. Uphold personal responsibility - Right of daughter to happy life with chosen partner. - Duty as father to teach right value of altruism & selflessness 2. Necessary to see my face in mirror again. As what kind of father will I be if I encroach on my daughters right for own selfish gains. 3. Uphold values of a politician, as a leader is one who knows the way, shows the way, goes the way ⇒ set right precedent for the society → action as example

This would fulfil my duties even if I have to lose my selfish gains for the larger good.