Topper Copies

A stone is thrown in such a manner that it would just hit a bird at the top of a tree and afterwards reach a height double that of the tree. If at the moment of throwing the stone the bird flies away horizontally, show that, notwithstanding this, the stone will hit the bird if its horizontal velocity be to that of the bird as $(\sqrt2 + 1) : 2$.

Shoham Teberiwal, AIR 77, 2023

Given a stone hits a bird & then a tree of double the height is attained

For a parabolic motion

Let it be projected at angle $\theta$ & velocity $= u$

[a sketch of a parabolic path from the origin at angle $\theta$ with velocity $u$, passing a bird at $(x_0, h/2)$ at the top of a tree of height $h/2$, rising to $h$]

At height $(h)$, $v_y = 0$

$\Rightarrow u_y^2 - 2gh = 0 \Rightarrow h_{max} = \dfrac{u_y^2}{2g}$

$\therefore$ bird at height $h_b = \dfrac{u^2\sin^2\theta}{4g} = \dfrac{h}{2}$

Now, if the bird is flying at horizontal velocity $= $ "$b$"

Let after time $t$ the stone hits bird

[a sketch of a parabola from the origin to a bird, $x_0$ and $x_0 + bt$ marked on the axis]

$\Rightarrow$ distance covered by bird $= bt$

$\Rightarrow$ coordinate of bird is $\left(bt + x_0, \dfrac{h}{2}\right)$

where $x_0$ is original place on tree (from origin)

For parabolic path

distance covered in time $t$ is $u_xt = u\cos\theta\, t$

$\Rightarrow bt + x_0 = u\cos\theta\, t$

$\Rightarrow t(u\cos\theta - b) = x_0$

& $\dfrac{h}{2} = u_yt - \dfrac{1}{2}gt^2$

From (1)

Let $\dfrac{u}{b} = k \Rightarrow$

From (1)

On solving

$\therefore$ ratio of speeds are $(\sqrt2 + 1 : 2)$