Mr. Y purchased 40 acres of land in a city located in the forested foothill for the construction of a place of religious worship by members of his community. The plans for the worship place called for numerous interconnected buildings, balconies, and water fountains. In addition to being a centre for worship, the place is intended to provide a residence for many worshippers who travel from far-off locations. Everyone looking at the plan agrees that the structure should prove to be extraordinarily beautiful. Ironically, the beauty of the site has become a chief cause for concern among the local residents of the area, a significant percentage of whom belong to a different religious community. Many of them believe that the place may become a tourist attraction, causing traffic problems and the degradation of the tranquil lifestyle of their neighbourhood. At the least, thousands of worshippers are expected to visit the place regularly. Many residents think their neighbourhood is not suitable for a facility of this size, nor for the number of people it is expected to accommodate. The congregation plans to have gatherings of up to 1,500 people, though only a single two-lane road approaches the site. The traffic, opponents argue, will cause commuting problems and introduce hazards on roads frequented by children and bicyclists. Increased traffic could also have an adverse impact on the environment. Meanwhile others see a more insidious reason behind the opposition: prejudice. They wonder if those who object to the worship place are motivated by religious biases. But those who oppose the construction insist that religion has nothing to do with it and they are opposed to any type of development that would lead to traffic congestion in the area. So, they just have an issue with the size and location in this case. In answer to the opposition, city planners have assured the residents that all of the city's guidelines and zoning regulations relevant to the area will be followed. They see no reason to stop the plan of construction. However, the opponents allege that the city planners have failed to prepare an adequate environmental impact report and, more importantly, did not properly notify residents, who are likely to be affected, while it was still in its nascent, flexible stages of planning. (a) You are a District Magistrate and the area lies in your jurisdiction. People from both sides have approached you with their grievances. What would you do to reconcile the two points of view? (b) Mention the merits and demerits of the following potential courses of action: (1) Ignore the opposition from the residents of the area and allow the place of religious worship to be built in accordance with the existing regulations. (2) Prohibit the construction, agreeing with the residents while causing distress among the thousands of worshippers counting on the new place of worship. (3) As a compromise, you place additional building regulations on the worship place or insist on modifications to the design.
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
This case presents the issues around religion and environment interlinked with each other, both of which are very sensitive topics.
This calls for true prudence and impartiality by the DM to uphold the right course of action. The integrity of the process needs to be upheld with objectivity to garner the trust of both sides.
(b) Options and their merits and demerits
1. Ignore the opposition & allow place of worship - existing regulation
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Promote tourism ⇒ economic benefits. | Huge possibility of law & order situation due to religion involved | | More local employment generated | Lack of EIA ⇒ Joshimath type crisis possible. |
2. Prohibit construction agreeing with residents → distress worshippers
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Support of locals guaranteed | Running away from responsibility ⇒ easy path | | Reduce pressure of tourist ⇒ uphold carrying capacity | Dereliction of duty towards worshippers. |
3. Additional building regulations or insist on design modifications
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Attempt to pacify both sides ⇒ "Madhyam Marg" | Loss of individual autonomy | | | Bureaucratic red tape |
(a) Reconciling the two As a DM would need deft emotional management & emotional intelligence.
1. Listen to both sides ⇒ establish trust → grievances heard. 2. Comprehensive EIA & SIA to find out all impacts of the construction 3. Ensure safety of roads → remove illegal encroachment to reduce congestion 4. Hold accountable earlier officer who didnt do SIA → "justice should not just be done but seen to be done" ⇒ popularize action → involve people. 5. Social audit involving both side representatives for trust building 6. Persuasion to allow the current design if according to norms → individual autonomy of creativity and Art. 25 of practicising religion, to Mr. Y 7. Provide all necessary provision for worshippers yet cap total no. of worshippers per day in area. → have Dharamshalas
Justification → This would uphold objectivity and participative action for trust building and environmental sustainability, learning from the cons of Joshimath ⇒ "A wise man learns from mistakes of others"