The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy.
Shakti Dubey, AIR 1, 2024
Siddhart Gautam was born in Lumbini. During his birth many sages were invited to bless the child. While many of them blessed him with great & luxurious life, one of the astrologers predicted that either he will be a great king or a monk.
This prediction disturbed his father who never wanted Siddhart to be a monk. That day he decided that he will provide all the comfort, convenience & wealth to his son, and Siddhart was never allowed to leave the palace.
One night, Gautama decided to go beyond the walls of the palace, so he went out on his horse "Kantak" while he was out he saw a sick man, a saint and a dead body. He saw the suffering of people and his subjects; this impacted him so much that he left the palace and went in search of Truth.
Later, after attaining Nirvana, he came to be known as Gautama Buddha, who later preached the ideas of peace, dharma and law of nature.
Thus, what comfort and convenience could not teach him, that challenges and controversial way of life did. This indicates that the true nature of man can be seen more in a distress situation than in a situation of comfort.
In this essay we will look at various dimensions of when & how circumstances have changed and shaped human character & how that has impacted humanity and contributed toward revolutionary changes.
It is said that - "A ship is safe in the harbour, but that is not what it is meant for". Similar is the case of humans, we assume comfort and a smooth journey are the best. But these are the controversial phases of failures & challenges that shape the character of a man.
Virat Kohli is the best example to understand this concept. He is one of the greatest cricket players of all time, but even he has seen the worst challenging phases in his career. Recently, in an interview after winning the T20 World Cup, he mentioned how those challenging phases have shaped his character not only as a cricketer but also as a man, because those are the times of introspection & hardwork; one who overcomes that tackles most of the problem on their own.
Every and anyone can uphold moral principles when the situation around is convenient, but to still stand by those principles during a time of challenge is an exhibition of strength of character.
Raja Ram Mohan Roy lived in a patriarchal society when he raised his voice against the oppression of women through practices like Sati & advocated for widow remarriage. He had to face backlash from the upper caste in society; the Dharma Sabha was formed by upper caste members who even approached the court. But Roy remained adamant on his principle, ultimately leading to the ban on Sati in 1828. This exhibition of strength of character is the ultimate measure of the kind of man he was; this is why he is known as the father of renaissance in India.
It was easy for him to choose a life of comfort & convenience & to go along with the nature of Indian society, but no!! He stood for what was right and not what was normal.
In this regard there is a very famous quote by Socrates who states, "Unexamined life is not worth living." Man must refine his character & must have the courage to step out of his comfort zone and gear up for the challenges. This is the ultimate measure of man.
Similarly, post World War II, the victors of the war assembled to ensure world peace, which led to the establishment of multilateral institutions like the United Nations, Bretton Woods institution, etc which was supposed to ensure world peace & help the poor & developing states.
During COVID-19, when the pandemic struck the world, there was chaos all around; poor & developing nations were facing the worst crisis because of a multiplicity of burdens. During such a crucial time, the victors of the world, the so-called "developed nations", went on to practice vaccine nationalism. During this time India, based on its principle of Vasudev Kutumbakam, under the Vaccine Maitri program, helped the developing & poor nations to manage the pandemic. These challenging times reveal the true character & true intention of these nations.
Thus it is rightly said that good times make us happy, but tough times make us strong.
Today in this globalised world, climate change is an international problem. The forerunners of the industrial revolution - like Britain, America, Japan, France, etc, which are also known as developed nations - have reaped the fruits of the benefits, while today the onus is on developing & least developed economies to mitigate & adapt to climate change. To ensure a level playing field, the international community came up with the idea of "common but differentiated responsibility", but the developed nations hardly feel that it's their responsibility to help the countries of the global south to tackle the issue. Which is very evident from the fact that the sum of $bn 100 which was proposed during the Paris Climate Deal (2015) is still not a reality.
Thus it is rightly said that when one wants to measure the character of a man/nation, that can be seen during complex & challenging times like these.
The easiest way is to follow the path that has already been created without analysing the positives & negatives, but it's not easy to choose the tough path where one knows that he/she might have to walk alone, because not everyone has the strength to face the challenges, but those who do, they are the ones who create the history.
Robert Frost in his poem "The Road Not Taken" has beautifully expressed this sentiment in the last line where he states - "... I chose the one less travelled by and that has made all the difference."
Doing the right thing when everyone is watching is easy, but still upholding the moral principle when no one is watching is a symbol of integrity & is the ultimate measure of man.
Nature provides a very beautiful example for this corollary - when dead & decaying matter is deposited, they form humus; when they are subjected to years of high pressure and temperature, it forms fossil fuel like coal, petroleum, etc, & when it is further exposed to even more adverse conditions, it becomes diamond. Chemically, humus, fossil fuel & diamond are all the same, ie, they are made up of carbon, but their worth varies; their value varies, the reason being their ability to face & survive harsh conditions which converts them into valuables.
Thus, it is true that the ultimate measure of man is not where he stands in moments of comfort & convenience, but in moments of challenges & controversies. Had Siddhart Gautam not chosen to step out of his comfort, he would have never become Gautama Buddha. Had Virat Kohli given up during his phase of bad performance, India would have lost one gem of a cricketer. Had Raja Ram Mohan Roy overlooked the challenges faced by women, had India overlooked the plight of small & developing nations during COVID-19, we would have a more gloomy picture of the world today.
Hence, we must understand that the roadblocks / speed breakers are not for disturbing our better experience of driving, rather these are to avoid the worst from happening to us, like accidents. So, humans must keep striving to be a better version of themselves, and for that we need to step out of our comfort zone.
As Mill says: "It is better to be a Socrates dissatisfied than a pig satisfied." Humans must keep nurturing themselves both through the tough & the good times, because it is the ultimate measure of the man.