Topper Copies

The tribunalisation of justice though considered to be an effective step is fraught with several challenges. Discuss in light of the Law Commission of India's report on the working of tribunals in India.

Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025

42nd Amendment Act introduced Article 323 A and 323 B, paving way for establishment of tribunal system in India.

Significance of Tribunal in Justice Delivery System - Faster disposal of cases - Inexpensive procedure - Flexibility (based on natural justice principle) - Recruitment of experts of domain. - Suo moto cognisance, eg NGT Yamuna Judgement.

Challenges in effective functioning 1. High Pendency of Cases: 44,000+ pending cases as per law commission Report, 2017. 2. Vacancy of post: 40% of post are currently vacant in CAT. 3. Overlapping jurisdiction and stand off with High court. 4. Against Article 50: involves executive into judicial process. 5. High cost of administration (14th finance commission) 6. To able to serve purpose of faster decision making.

Way forward - National Tribunal Commission as per L Chandra Case Judgement - Faster & time bound disposal of case. - Reforming appointment process

Government brought Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021 to solve the issue of vacancy and retirement, more such structural reforms to fast track tribunals are needed.