To what extent has the anti-defection law been able to address the issue of political instability in India? Discuss with suitable arguments.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Schedule 10 and Article 102(b) on talks of disqualification of MP/MLA for defection from one party to other
Anti Defection law : In solving political instability 1. Lowered the number of defection among legislature from 1960s 2. Acts as determent: disqualification 3. Punishment from people for defecting politician by not electing him again 4. Upholds will of people
Anti defection law : Failed to curb instability 1. Still defection is common culture, eg in 2017-22, 67% of legislature in Goa assembly changed party (ADR Report) 2. Political instability & resort politics, eg Madhya Pradesh & Karnataka in 2020. 3. Rising role of money and muscle power in politics 4. Allows wholesale defection but not retail defection (2/3rd exception of merger) 5. Wide powers to speaker: no time period for action; may lack legal expertise on issue. 6. Blurs distinction between dissent and defection among legislature
Way forward - Transferring power from Speaker to governor for ADL proceedings (Goswami Committee) - Constituting an independent committee to solve defection (SC in Karnataka MLA case) - Time bound resolution of disputes (Halim Committee) - Removing merger provision
Anti-Defection law in current form changed culture from 'Aaya Ram, Yaya Ram' to 'Hey Ram!' and thus must be reformed.