A dysfunctional criminal justice system, absence of well-considered legislation and need for domain expertise, are being seen as the new challenges for the Indian judiciary. Discuss.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
India follows a colonial era criminal Justice System with focussing more on jail not bail as the rule.
Challenges for Judiciary
1. Dysfunctional Criminal Justice System i. Colonial era provisions ii. Jail not bail as underlying Principle iii. High pendancy of Cases (4.7 crore pending cases) iv. High number of undertrials in jail (67% prisoner are undertrial) v. Non Contradictory provision & exemption in legal System
2. Absence of well considered legislation i. Laws ending up before court, eg NJAC, CAA, J&K Bill, 2019 ii. Passing laws by legislature in haste: lower sittings (70 in 2021 from 120 in 1947); money bill route to bypass Rajya Sabha. iii. Non-regulation of certain Crimes by legislature, eg Marital Rape iv. Providing rights to vulnerable, eg LGBTQ + marriage recognition
3. Need for domain expertise i. Complex issues before court like crypto currency ban, Stock market scam ii. Judges doesnot know nitty gritty & fine nuances of judgement. iii. Increase in specialisation due to technology & globalisation required specialised domain expert.
Way forward - Reforming criminal justice system, 'bail not jail' a rule (2nd ARC) - Creating specialised tribunals for subject of expertise, eg NGT. - Capacity building and training of judicial officers. - Only passing laws after due consideration
New era of technology will bring new problems for Judiciary. Proper capacity building and specialised expertise is way forward.