Discuss the impact of the proclamation of National Emergency on Fundamental Rights in India. Also, highlight the various Supreme Court judgments in this context.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Article 352 of Constitution empowers President to proclaim national emergency in case there is threat to sovereignty of nation due to war, external aggression or armed rebellion
Impact of proclamation of National Emergency on Rights 1. Article 358 asks for automatic suspension of rights under Article 19 in case of Emergency on grounds of external factors 2. Article 359 asks for suspension by proclamation during National Emergency 3. Article 20 and 21 cannot be taken away during emergency.
Supreme Court Judgement 1. In ADM Jabalpur case, HR Khanna held that personal liberty is paramount, even during emergency 2. In Minerva Mills Case (1980) SC held that Article 20 and 21 cannot be suspended in Emergency. 3. Emergency only suspends enforcement for time period and people can claim violation of rights during emergency, once period gets over.
The 44th Amendment Act and ADM Jabalpur case were significant in curtailing misuse of emergency provision