Prove that the ideal $\langle x \rangle$ in $Q[x]$ is maximal but not maximal in $Z[x]$.
Shoham Teberiwal, AIR 77, 2023
Given two rings $Q[x]$ and $Z[x]$
for $Z[x]$ we show $\langle x \rangle$ is not maximal ideal
consider $S = (2, x)$
$\therefore$ ideal generated by $S$ will be $(S) = \{ 2f(x) + x g(x) \mid f(x) \;\&\; g(x) \in Z[x] \}$
clearly $\langle x \rangle \subset S \subset Z[x]$
Hence $\langle x \rangle$ is not maximal ideal in $Z[x]$
(ii) for ring $Q[x]$
we know that $Q$ is a field $\therefore$ $(Q, +^n)$ abelian group $(Q^*, \times^n)$ abelian group & $\times^n$ distributive over $+^n$
we know that if F is a field then F[x] is Eucledian domain ($\because$ division algorithm will be applicable) $\therefore$ Q[x] will be E.D.
Now, we show E.D. is Principal Ideal Domain
let d(x) = set of all non-negative values let d(b) is smallest possible value $\therefore$ the ideal containing b will be principal ideal
$\because$ b = aq + r r = 0 (or) d(r) < d(b) not possible as d(b) is smallest
$\Rightarrow r = 0$ $\therefore$ b = aq $\Rightarrow$ b is principal ideal
Now $\mathbb{Q}[x]$ is P.I.D.
we show in P.I.D. any ideal I is maximal
on contrary let it be not maximal $\therefore$ $\exists$ ideal U such that $I \subset U \subset$ P.I.D.
$U = I + (a)$ let $b \in U$ but $b \notin I$ $\therefore$ $U = (b)$ since its PID $\Rightarrow$ $I \subset (b)$, $a \notin I$ $\Rightarrow$ $I + (a) = (b)$, let $I = (c)$ $\Rightarrow$ $(c) + (a) = (b)$ $cx + ay \in (b)$ $\therefore$ $1 \in (b)$ which is a contradiction $(b) = $ P.I.D.
hence ideal I is maximal
$\Rightarrow$ $\langle x \rangle$ ideal in P.I.D. $\mathbb{Q}[x]$ is maximal