No one can make you feel inferior without your consent.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Maya Angelou famously said that "you can trod me in the very dirt, but still, like dust, I rise". Her words, filled with defiance against injustice, point to a fundamental truth. There is a gap between what happens to us and how we respond to it - and in that gap lies the freedom to choose our response. Eleanour Roosevelt famously said that "no one can make you feel inferior without your consent" attuned to the idea that another person's treatment of meting out indignity is simply the stimulus. One still has a choice in how one interprets the indignity - as proof of the other's prejudice or one's own inferiority. Hence, Viktor Frankl famously argued that the very attitude we take towards our suffering is the sole, surviving inalienable freedom, which remains even when all other freedoms have been stripped away, such as in a Nazi concentration camp.
This insight is especially crucial in our present world where discrimination is often covert rather than overt, and inequality is implied, rather than expressly stated.
I. Systemic Discrimination and the Dialectics of Inferiority
Discrimination in the modern world is no longer tolerated in its earlier forms of physical segregation, legal exclusion, and deprivation of citizenship rights. Rather, it is increasingly more insidious, covert and systemic. It is manifest in unequal access to opportunities, leading to limitations in choice in determining life outcomes. This leads to an unequal distribution of dignity under the guise of "meritocracy".
This can be illustrated through two distinct examples. At the societal level, this can be seen in systemic racism in the U.S. African American neighbourhoods are overcrowded, underfunded, and minimally serviced by a fund-strapped public school infrastructure and prohibitively expensive healthcare. African youth, seeing opportunities for legitimate social mobility diminish, are derailed into crime, precarious living conditions on the margins of society. Despite a grossly unequal starting point, they are judged on common American 'meritocratic' standards, and seen as "uncouth, uncivilized" and thus "inferior".
Similarly, on the global level, we see what Wallerstein describes as a "World System" of unequal relations between the developed and developing countries where developed countries are seen as "modernized economies", "generously giving aid and technology" to the third world. A reading of modern Indian history quickly acquaints us with a historical fact unmasking this facade - as Dadabhai Naoroji pointed out more than a hundred years ago, the very prosperity of the Western World was based on drain of wealth from the Colonies. This unjust drain led to increasing enrichment of the Global North at the cost of the Global South and persists as neocolonialist relations of unfair trade terms, debt trap diplomacy and attempts to use "aid" to undermine strategic autonomy.
Thus, systems are rigged to create "winners" and "losers", the "advanced" and the "backward". Louis Dumont presents a fascinating insight - unequal systems, such as the caste system, are grounded in ideology that places the unequals in hierarchy and opposition. Thus, Dumont argues that caste system is based on principles of purity and pollution, where the "pure" is described with respect to, and superior to the "impure". Thus we see two categories like "civilized" and "savage", "developed" and "underdeveloped". These categories underscore the superiority of one and the inferiority of the other. Frankl's notion of fundamental freedom of interpretation would ask us to investigate and dismantle these constructed hierarchies that place some people at a pedestal and "trod others to the very dirt". But how must one accomplish this?
II. Contesting Hegemony to Assert Pride
Gramsci described the concept of Hegemony as the ability of the ruling class to justify their rule by shaping the norm. This enables them to rule by the "consent of the oppressed". Sen illustrates this in the Indian context, where women are often the "last and least to eat". Here, value system of welfare of the family preceding the individual woman leads to the woman not seeking to renegotiate access to food and other entitlements, rather accepting them as just and fair.
Thus injustice can only be wreaked on individuals upon convincing them of their inferiority - that they deserve less, and must ask for less. Even though socially constructed, an "inferior identity" can be greatly enshackling, constraining even the thought of subverting it.
To overcome it and regain autonomy, one must investigate the notion of inferiority which is being imposed. Kant famously said that the enlightenment is simply the "ability to think for oneself". Often, underlying impositions of inferiority are vested interests, like colonial conquest, or patriarchal exploitation.
Dr Ambedkar famously noted that education was crucial in developing the ability to reason, enshrined in his motto - "educate, agitate, organize". And it is through reason that we can contest externally imposed inferiority. At a societal level, we must construct a counter-culture that takes pride in identity. This involves taking back autonomy to define oneself and refusing to believe in false narratives of inferiority. The present Government's efforts at Atmanirbharta to uphold economic self-reliance point towards a choice to refuse the "aid based" developmental model of dependency upon the Global North and rather asserting our economic autonomy and equality. moreover, we need systemic change that no longer seeks to put people in hierarchical relations of superior and inferior.
III. Reconstituting Society on Principles of Tolerance, Justice and Inclusion
The fundamental principle to systemic change would be moving past seeking to place individuals on a "ranking" and appreciating differences instead. This is based in the idea of multiculturalism that gives equal respect to all cultures, languages, religions and customs and its essence is enshrined in Swami Vivekananda's speech at Chicago, where he said that "we regard all religions as true and equal paths to the divine" - indicating the idea that two different things can be simultaneously true, without one thing having to be better or worse than the other.
we must also recalibrate the focus of institutions from considerations of merit to focus on enhancing the quality of life of the maximum number of people. Mihir Shah has outraged the Indian education system, with its focus on ranks in boards and competitive exams as being an "excellent filtration system" that filters out the "cream of talent" while the rest are left to their own devices. The NEP has acknowledged this structural flaw and is redirecting focus on dropouts, 'catch-up education', adult education and foundational literacy and numeracy, thus broadening systemic focus away from "merit-based exclusion" to human development orientation.
At this point, it is necessary to clarify that a social system that refuses to classify people as superior or inferior isn't against objective assessments and constructive criticism. Rather, it is against generalizing criticisms to reach the conclusion of overall inferiority of a people or nation.
Thus, the founders of the Indian Renaissance were open to Occidentalist critique of Indian society in terms of untouchability, sati, prominence to superstition etc. However, they refused to allow our society to be characterized as backward. Rather, they investigated our past to prove that many of the social evils were secondary accretions on a largely tolerant, dialogical and scientific culture. However, they were no revivalists - they understood that questioning imposed inferiority and asserting pride did not mean blindly reviving the past, or self congratulatory chest thumping. Rather, it meant the courage to look at oneself and one's society objectively, and to say that despite its flaws - one's identity or society is worthy of equal respect and love. The acts of reform, critique and improvement then become labours of love for the full expansion of human potential.
And this, really, is the heart of my argument: between the gap of external treatment and our response, we must each practice this form of objective, yet empathetic love - being fully willing to see our flaws yet firmly refusing to see ourselves as "inferior" or "less than" anyone else.