You have recently been posted as a Nodal Education Officer in one of the districts, where mass cheating in examinations is a regular phenomenon. Media reports have shown parents and relatives scaling school walls and buildings to pass answer chits to students taking secondary school examinations in the district. Moreover, with the advent of new technological devices, cheating in examinations has become more sophisticated and exam rules are flouted openly. On investigation, it has come to your notice that these rackets are run by many school authorities, including exam invigilators who are mostly teachers, and they are hand in glove for profits. With a shortage of staff, invigilators threaten go on mass strikes if any action is taken. Conducting the exams, cancelling them on account of cheating and having re-exams are a loss of time and money for the government and this vicious cycle goes on. As the Nodal Education Officer of the district, address the following questions: (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) How will you resolve the issues in the given case? (c) What long-term strategy needs to be adopted to deal with the menace of cheating in various examinations?
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
Schools are the first place where children learn ethics, and moral corruption at this temple of education is a strong sign of decadence for society.
(a) Ethical issues in the case 1. Loss of trust of integrity or integral children in the process 2. Corruption as a termite eating the school system. 3. Parents as first school of child supporting cheating ⇒ culture of loss of integrity 4. New technology use for cheating ⇒ education without character (sin) 5. Invigilators violating the law of universality ⇒ promoting cheating 6. Dilemma before Nodal Officer → to conduct exam with cheating → slippery slope, or cancel exam → fiscally not prudent
(b) Resolving issues at the case Would need my crisis of conscience resolution & courage of conviction, along with the wholistic approach of bringing Rawlsian justice to all.
1. Talk to the invigilators and convince them → use Dillard's fear theory initially → tell them they would lose jobs. 2. Prevent threat of mass strike → identify the rational among the invigilators and use persuasion to make them comply → appeal to conscience 3. Nukkad/natak to break the culture of cheating → bring parents of someone who succeeded in academics for social proofing 4. Enquiry and action against all school staff involved in cheating → set the right precedent 5. Extra invigilators after profiling → to ensure low risk of moral corruption of these new ones.
(c) Long term measures 1. Survey of all walls and cheating methods - how all technology is being used → data driven decision 2. Plug all loopholes → scanners to prevent tech infiltration in exam hall → barricading and thorns on the walls at top. 3. Overhauling of teaching - Better teacher assessment so that students understand topics. - Recommend necessary teaching tests to ensure good teachers. 4. Attitudinal change of parents - Bring in local leaders to spread the importance of integrity in exam for future. 5. School staff would need flying squads and Samkalp patras for better integrity and probity in school administration
Justification - This would uphold my duty as per Kantian Categorical imperative and show students the importance of short term pain for long term gain.