Despite having features borrowed from Constitutions of various other countries, the Constitution of India remains unique. Discuss. (Answer in 200 words)
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Indian Constitution is the largest constitution of world. It has certain provision borrowed from different constitutions of the world.
A bag of Borrowing - Most of provision of the constitution are taken from Government of India Act, 1935 - Borrows provision like Fundamental Rights, election of president from USA - Different provision borrowed from different countries
| Provision | Borrowed from | |---|---| | DPSP | Ireland | | Union with strong centre | Canada | | Bicameral legislature | Britain | | Fundamental duties | Russia |
Unique features - All the things borrowed were modified as per Indian needs and requirement. - Innovative features and Articles (Article 40, 42, 356 etc) - Not an ordinary federation but Indian federation is federation - sui-generis. - Parliamentary innovations like Zero hour, question hour etc. - Provisions of affirmative actions by State to uplift the depressed caste and tribes. - Limitations of the rights are also included simultaneously, making rights crystal & clear.
Dr Ambedkar was criticised about constitution being a borrowed bag in the constituent assembly. Babasaheb not only acknowledged about borrowing certain parts but also highlighted the need to adopt international best practices tested over the time.
Calling the constitution a bag of borrowing will be a narrow understanding of the same. The constitution although borrowed some provisions but modified them as per Indian needs.