Topper Copies

Highlight the various challenges in ensuring cooperative federalism in India. Also, suggest measures to foster cooperative federalism. (Answer in 200 words)

Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025

Supreme Court in Mohit Minerals Case (2022) described Indian federalism as a dialogue between cooperative and uncooperative federalism.

Challenges in ensuring cooperative federalism in India - Political Agendas - Difference in political view points of centre and state is a main flashpoint, where each tries to establish her ideology superior. - Concurrent Jurisdiction of Bodies - Bodies like CBI, ED, NCB have concurrence with local forces - State often accuse that these agencies are used to harass them. - No independent body to foster coordination, manage bargain and conflict resolution - Niti Aayog although tries to foster cooperative federalism, is accused of bias towards centre. - Centralisation of Power - Redistribution of power in favour of centre - GST has made states more financially dependent on centre. - Trust deficit is increasing between centre and state - Office of Governor - Governor used to keep check on State government as agent of centre. - In states of West Bengal, Tamil Nadu, Kerala etc, the governors action has made cooperative federalism weak.

Measures to foster cooperative federation - Adopting major recommendations of Sarkaria and Punchi Commission - Office of governor to be apolitical - Fiscal federalism for states - Use of Article 356 as a last resort. - Extending mandate of Inter State Council. - Consulting with States when Centre signs an international agreement. - No misusing of central investigating agencies - Transparency and effective coordination among centre and states.

The Covid-19 pandemic has served us vital reminder about the need to mutually cooperate and review the cooperative spirit of Indian federalism to tackle national contigencies and to ensure citizen centric administration.