Rina and her friends from the college were working as interns with a company for the last few months. On completion of their internship, some of them, including Rina, have been offered full-time jobs in the company. Being a reputed company, she and her friends accepted the offer. Rina is enthusiastic about her new job and has even established good relationship with some of her company co-workers during her internship. However, during her tenure as an intern, Rina had begun to notice that one of the Vice-Presidents (VPs) of the company was giving her too much attention. He used to make an extra effort to stop by Rina's cubicle and chat, something he was not doing with any of the other interns. He had even tried to connect with Rina over social networking sites. Some of her co-interns also noticed this and began to make offhand comments to Rina about the extra attention being given by the VP. Now that she has been hired for a full time position, she is fearful that she might have to work with this VP directly. While he has not done or said anything explicitly inappropriate, the extra attention and the fact that her co-workers noticed it, made her very uncomfortable and undermined her concentration at work. The company encourages an open and friendly atmosphere and when she was hired, it was communicated to her that she should always speak to her Manager whenever faced with any uncomfortable work related issues. However, she is concerned to speak about it officially, as the VP has not explicitly done anything wrong. In the given situation: (a) What dilemmas does Rina face? (b) What options does she have? Provide the merits and demerits of each. (c) Highlight the course of action she should adopt, along with justification for the same.
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
Sexual Harassment at Workplace Act 2013 has clear guidelines to protect women at workplace. Yet, the #MeToo movement highlighted its toothlessness.
(a) Dilemmas faced by Rina 1. Professional duty to uphold work culture of collegiality vs personal uncomfortable mental agony. 2. Short term pain of complaining and face VP wrath vs long term gain of setting precedent 3. Lack of breaking of letter of law by the VP vs breaking the spirit of the law, as harassment is mental & not just legal.
(b) Options in front of Rina
1. Complain to internal complaint authority
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Own peace of mind. | Lack of evidence | | Prevent same behaviour with other girls | VP may be truly innocent & only perception |
2. Confront the VP about attention
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Right to be heard given ⇒ natural justice | VP may deny all allegation | | Chance for introspection to both party. | Chances of professional troubles. | | | Loss of office relationships |
3. Collect girls & launch protest
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Collective action with awareness | Sets wrong precedent of quick to protest ⇒ slippery slope | | Against the value of Gandhi deontology | Against the duty dictum of Kant to adopt easy route |
(c) Course of Action Rina's course of action must be guided by fortitude & the duty to set the right precedent to protect other girls from similar things too.
1. Talk to the VP for collecting right information → dont judge based on perception ⇒ call for objectivity 2. If not convinced, complain to the internal committee → due process 3. If still not get justice → spread awareness among other women and adopt united action to pressurize for company reforms. 4. Last option of police complaint and eventual protest to show that Satyamen jayate.
Justification → The silence of the good has done more harm than the vices of the evil. Taking inspiration from the wrestlers' protest, all perpetrators must be brought to justice even if it means loss of employment, as mental peace and clear conscience is necessary for any wholesomeness of character with courage of conviction.