[?]ative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Lateral entry in civil services involves appointment of middle & higher level public officials from private sectors or public sector enterprises bypassing competitive examination (like UPSC)
Lateral entry - Reformative step - Include expertise -(eg) Nandan Nilekani for NITI Aayog, incorporate specialisation. - Reform work culture change from laid back 'sarkari' attitude. Brings efficiency, effectiveness and discipline of private sector - Fuels innovation Develop new and out of box ideas in governance - Hybridisation Combine governance objective with resource optimisation - Citizen as customer incorporate culture of citizen centricity with best quality of service delivery to the customer. Strengthens feedback mechanism for incremental progress.
Concerns with lateral Entry - Absence of social justice lack of reservation & affirmative action (Eg) UPSC cancelled lateral entry notification for lack of reservation - Resistance from Public officials - Harm their promotion trajectory. Reduced their morale for work - Profit orientation Private sector has profit as goal -> may compromise with public interest - Lack of experience in governance - Specialisation in job doesn't translate to effective management governance - Collusion - subject to state's patronisation & discretion, impact merit in public service - Salary & Service conditions - lower than private sector & different can cause lack of interest of experienced professional
Way Forward - Balance of Both - Training of public servant - Mission Karmayogi (iGOT platform) - Specialisation (suggested by PL Hota Committee) - Contractual appointments - short term contract for lateral entry; pilot study of effectiveness - Collaborative work - Private - Public collaboration through joint working group
Lateral entry can be experimented as a trial & implemented large scale Post outcome analysis to enhance aim of 'perform, reform & transform' civil service (PM Modi)